Whatever the worst commenters on Reddit may say, as CIR members, we believe that physicians shouldn’t have to sacrifice all of ourselves for the sake of our medical training. At Mount Sinai Morningside and West Hospitals in Manhattan, more than 500 doctors just won a historic elective egg freezing benefit because they prioritized supporting the whole doctor – and crucially, because they were willing to fight.
As part of the doctors’ new collective bargaining agreement, ratified on September 17, the elective egg freezing benefit is a first-of-its-kind win for CIR physicians in NYC. Dr. Camelia Malkami, an OB-GYN resident at Morningside and West, said that winning the egg freezing proposal was at the center of CIR’s negotiations with Mount Sinai from the start of bargaining this past March.
“This coverage is critical, because women physicians especially face serious challenges having families — and it’s our belief as a union that we should be supported as whole people during our training, not just cogs in a machine,” said Dr. Malkami.
Determined to win strong wages and benefits, including the egg freezing coverage, the Mount Sinai residents and fellows took action throughout negotiations. Over the course of bargaining, the physicians repped CIR purple in a sticker up action at their hospitals, delivered a supermajority petition to the administration, flyered in front of the hospital, spoke out on social media and to the press, at local community board meetings, and in meetings with electeds, and more.
Physicians won the hearts of elected officials and Manhattan’s west side community with their advocacy; the doctors’ sibling unions, Community Board 4, and dozens of politicians signed on to support letters directed at Mount Sinai. Along with the funding for egg freezing, the Mount Sinai physicians’ new contract includes pay increases of 12% over three years, a $1500 annual meal allowance, ratification bonuses, and more.
For many of the doctors, their fight at the table came from a place of deep love for their patients and a passion for their careers. Though she doesn’t deny that residency is exhausting, Dr. Malkami finds a strong sense of purpose in her work, which sometimes includes counseling patients around elective egg freezing and other fertility treatments.
“Especially in OB-GYN, you get to be with people through the best and worst times in their lives. I really want to educate women about their bodies, advocate for funding into women’s health conditions, erase some of the stigma around seeking help for some of these things.”
Through CIR, Dr. Malkami and her coworkers have increased their own sense of autonomy and well-being – both economically and in terms of starting families. Dr. Malkami says her new contract is “life-changing.”
Because their win sets an important precedent at CIR hospitals in NYC, the impact of the Mount Sinai victory could be similarly transformative for many doctors–and for years to come.






